• Freeedom

    The Great American State Fair opened on June 25th on the National Mall. It was supposed to run sixteen days and celebrate the 250th anniversary of the nation’s founding. It was supposed to be a world’s fair, a unifying spectacle, a moment that transcended the noise.

    It lasted about forty minutes before the Ferris wheel broke down.

    The generator powering the wheel failed on opening day. The ice cream melted in the food hall from the same power cut. The Reflecting Pool, freshly refinished at taxpayer expense in a shade Trump personally named “American flag blue,” had already begun peeling, chunks of blue sealant floating in a spreading algae bloom that turned the water green. Trump assured the crowd it looked perfect.

    This is the administration’s relationship with visible reality: it does not apply to them.

    Before the fair even opened, the concert lineup had collapsed. Martina McBride withdrew. The Commodores withdrew. Bret Michaels withdrew. Young MC withdrew. Morris Day and The Time withdrew. Each cited the same thing: they were told this was a nonpartisan celebration of America, and they had been lied to. When the whole roster evaporated, Trump declared the musicians “overpriced” and their music “boring,” and announced what he called “A Rally to End All Rallies.” The 250th anniversary of American independence would become a campaign event. The distinction, apparently, no longer warranted mentioning.

    The last performer standing was Vanilla Ice, who explained that he would play for anyone, up to and including Putin. He then had his show canceled two hours before showtime, due to “inclement weather.” The rain that fell was real. What requires no weather report is the other reason the organizers kept reaching for that excuse: there was almost no one there to send home.

    At the opening night rally, the crowd numbered around a thousand. That is not an estimate from critics. That is the number reported by journalists on the ground. Roughly half of those in attendance wore Trump merchandise. One man said it was his 116th Trump rally. For the faithful, the 250th birthday of the republic was a backdrop. The main event was, as always, the man himself.

    Fox News was there to provide context. Correspondent Kevin Corke stood on camera in front of a visibly sparse lawn and announced, “I’m not kidding, I think there were thousands.” His colleagues nodded. The cameras did not lie. Fox News did.

    This is the instruction manual for the remaining faithful: ignore what you can see. The crowds are there, just out of frame. The Reflecting Pool looks perfect. The fair is a triumph. You may not trust your own eyes, but you may trust us, and we will tell you what your eyes missed.

    About a fifth of the nation’s states declined to send official delegations or spend public money on participation. That is not a protest by radicals. That is governors and state officials, including Republicans, deciding that this event did not represent them or their constituents. The fair billed itself as nonpartisan. It was chaired by Donald Trump. These two facts were not reconcilable, and the people who knew it kept their distance.

    The administration’s Transportation Secretary, Sean Duffy, opened the rally. His children stood next to him on a federally permitted stage in front of the Washington Monument. He looked at the sparse crowd that had gathered to mark the beginning of America’s 250th year, and he said this: “Way better than those libtards that canceled on us.”

    That is the Secretary of Transportation of the United States. That is the warmup act for a semiquincentennial celebration. That is what this administration chose to offer the nation on the occasion of its 250th birthday, in front of a monument to the man who refused to be king.

    And then there is this guy. If you know, you know.

    I was eight years old in 1976. I remember the Bicentennial the way you remember something that settled into you before you had words for what settling meant. The grade school lessons, the Schoolhouse Rock episodes, the understanding that something large was being marked. The Smithsonian ran a twelve-week Festival of American Folklife on the National Mall that year. More than four and a half million people came. Independence Hall in Philadelphia welcomed twice its usual annual visitors. Tall ships from thirty nations paraded past the Statue of Liberty while six million people lined the waterfront. Nobody had to be told the crowds were there just out of frame.

    1976 was not a golden year for American politics. Gerald Ford had just pardoned Nixon. The country had spent the better part of a decade metabolizing assassinations, Vietnam, Watergate, and recession. The wounds were real. But Ford did not make the Bicentennial about himself. He did not need the celebration to tell him he was winning. He marked it and stepped aside, because the occasion was larger than the man who happened to hold the office.

    What this country got instead, fifty years later, was a Ferris wheel that stopped working, a pool that turned green, a concert roster that fled, a crowd that could fit inside a midsize auditorium, and a Cabinet secretary calling the absent performers “libtards” while his children watched.

    The billboard outside the fair announcing the weather closure spelled it “Freeedom 250.” Three e’s. The internet noticed immediately. One observer said the extra E stood for Epstein. Another said the freedom to misspell was in the Constitootin. The comparisons to the Fyre Festival arrived without prompting from anyone, because they were obvious to anyone.

    The organizers put out a statement. “Red states, blue states, and everything in between, coming together ahead of our nation’s 250th anniversary — and somehow that’s not the story.”

    They are correct that it is not the story. The story is what was there. The peeling pool. The broken wheel. The empty lawn. The last available performer, canceled for weather. The Secretary of Transportation, at a national celebration, deploying a slur that fuses a political identity with a clinical disability, while standing in front of the Washington Monument with his children.

    Two hundred and fifty years. It is an extraordinary thing that this republic has lasted as long as it has, given everything it has asked of itself and been asked to absorb. The generation of 1776 knew the experiment might fail. The generation of 1861 almost let it. The generation of 1945 saved it at a price that should never be spoken of casually. Every generation has been handed something imperfect and asked to do better.

    This administration was handed a 250th anniversary and turned it into a rally. It was handed a chance at a unifying moment and used it to call half the country a name. It was handed the Washington Monument and stood in front of it to complain about singers.

    You do not have to love this president to mourn what he did with this occasion. You only have to love the country enough to know the difference between honoring it and exploiting it.

    The fair runs through July 10th. The Ferris wheel may be repaired by then. The pool may clear. The crowds may come. Or the weather may again prove inclement, and the faithful will be told to go home and trust that thousands were there, just out of frame.

    The truth needs no such alibi. It is standing right in front of you, in three e’s, on a sign outside an empty field, on the 250th birthday of the United States of America.

    Gerald Ford marked the Bicentennial and stepped aside, because the occasion was larger than the man who held the office.

    Donald Trump looked at the 250th anniversary of the United States of America and saw a rally for himself he hadn’t thrown yet.

    That is the whole difference. That is the whole problem.

    And if you can’t see that, don’t worry. It’s just the camera angle.